Director says "Make it pop" is not a note. It is a wish. Tell me what to change and I will make it pop.

How to give feedback on a video so the next version is better

Updated · 5 min read · by the Nine crew

Good video feedback names the moment, says what to change, and says why. Watch once without stopping, then review in order: message, story, pictures, words, sound. Collect everyone's notes into one list, and let one person decide.

A black and white photograph of a film joining room: six women and a man at benches with reels of film, a splicer, strips of film hanging over the edges and small tins spread on a table.
The assembling and joining room at the Lubin Company studio in Philadelphia, 1914. Where a note becomes a cut. anonymous photographer, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Your idea, ready to go“A 20-second film for my law firm, Clarke & Hale: clear advice for small businesses, a fixed-price first meeting, and no jargon.”

Make this film

Sign up takes a minute. The idea is filled in, and you can change every word.

Almost every slow revision round is slow for the same reason: the note said how somebody felt, and the person making the film had to guess what to change. Guessing takes a version. Sometimes two.

This page is how to review a video, yours or a supplier's, so the next version is closer and the one after that is done.

What makes a good video note?

A good note has three parts: where, what, why. "At 0:12, the price is on screen for less than a second; hold it for two seconds, because people need time to read it." Anyone can act on that note.

Vague noteClear note
Make it more exciting.The first three seconds are a logo. Start with the problem instead.
The music is off.From 0:20 the music is louder than the voice. Lower it under the voice.
I do not like the colours.Use our dark green from the website for the backgrounds, not the light blue.
Too slow.Cut the pause between 0:08 and 0:11.
Can it feel more like us?We never say "solutions". Replace it with "help" in the voice and the titles.
Tip from Director Write notes as if the editor has never met you. Because, at 11 pm on a deadline, they effectively have not.

How to review a video, step by step

  1. Step 1

    Watch it once without stopping. Like a viewer would. Write down only your first impression in one line.

  2. Step 2

    Check the message. After one viewing, can you say what the film wants people to know and do? If not, that is the first note, and the most important.

  3. Step 3

    Check the story. Does it start fast enough, and does it end on the action you want?

  4. Step 4

    Check the pictures. Brand colours, logo, people, places. Anything wrong or missing.

  5. Step 5

    Check the words. Spelling, names, numbers, prices, titles on screen.

  6. Step 6

    Check the sound. Voice clear, music under the voice, no sudden jumps in volume.

  7. Step 7

    Watch it on a phone with the sound off. Most people will. Can they still follow it?

Feedback examples for the usual problems

Most notes on a short film are about the same few things. Here is how to write each one so it can be fixed in one go.

  • A slow start: "Cut the first two seconds. Open on the line 'Your windows, clean every month.'"
  • A message that is not clear: "After watching, I could not say what we want people to do. Add 'Book online in a minute' at the end, on screen."
  • Text that is hard to read: "At 0:15 the white text sits on a light sky. Make the text larger, or put it on a dark band."
  • A wrong detail: "At 0:09 the van shows our old logo. Use the new one, attached."
  • Pacing: "The middle part, 0:10 to 0:18, is rushed against the voice. Give each picture one more second."
  • An ending that fades out: "End on the web address for three full seconds, then cut to black."

Notice that every example has a place in the film, a change, and often a reason. Attach what you can: the new logo, the right photo, the exact wording. An attachment beats a description every time.

Collecting notes from a team

Five people watching separately will send five lists, some of which contradict each other. The person making the film should not have to referee.

  • Name one person who decides. Everyone else sends notes to them.
  • Set a deadline for notes, and do not send a second batch after the edit has started.
  • Merge the lists into one, in the order of the film, with time stamps.
  • Mark each note: must change, nice to have, or question.
  • Send it once. One clear list beats ten emails.

How many revisions are normal?

For a short film, two revision passes usually get it right: one for the big things (message, story, order), one for the small things (words, timing, sound). A third round is often a sign that the first notes were vague, or that someone new joined late. If you are on round four, go back to the one-sentence message and check that everyone still agrees on it.

Notes that cost money

  • Changing the script after the voice is recorded. Settle the words before the voice.
  • New people in the last round. Show the boss the first version, not the last.
  • Notes on taste with no reason. "I prefer blue" restarts the debate. "Our brand is green" ends it.
  • Notes that contradict an earlier note without saying so.

Giving notes on a Nine film

A client can watch a Nine film through a private review link with no account and pin notes to the exact moment, then say Approved or Changes needed; letting a client see a film and give notes shows how. You can also change many things yourself, like colours, pace and word size, in the chamber. For timing, see how long an animated video takes.

Questions people ask

How do you give constructive feedback on a video?

Name the moment with a time stamp, say exactly what to change, and give a short reason. "At 0:12, hold the price on screen for two seconds, people need time to read it." Avoid notes that only describe a feeling, like "make it pop".

What should I check when reviewing a video?

In this order: the message (can you say it after one viewing?), the story (fast start, clear end), the pictures (brand, people, places), the words (names, numbers, spelling) and the sound (voice clear, music under it). Then watch it on a phone with the sound off.

How many revision rounds does a video need?

Usually two for a short film: one for the big things like message and order, one for the small things like words and timing. More rounds are often a sign of vague notes or new people joining late.

How do I collect video feedback from several people?

Name one person who decides, set a deadline for notes, merge everything into one list in the order of the film with time stamps, and mark each note as must change, nice to have, or question. Send the list once.

What is a time-stamped video note?

A note that starts with the exact time in the video, like "0:23", so the editor can find the moment at once. It saves guessing and back-and-forth, and makes it clear which notes are about the same scene.

Your idea, ready to go“A 20-second film for my law firm, Clarke & Hale: clear advice for small businesses, a fixed-price first meeting, and no jargon.”

Make this film

Sign up takes a minute. The idea is filled in, and you can change every word.

How-to & craftCreatives